Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Career / Work · Advice & Questions ·

We're voting for a team lead, but nobody says what the vote decides

Career / Work category photographCareer / Work

Our manager sent a form asking which of three colleagues should become team lead. It has one box for a name and no explanation of how the answers will be used.

I welcome being asked. We will work with the person every day. But colleagues have started discussing who is likely to win, and I don't know whether this is a binding vote, one source of feedback or a way to choose whom to interview.

I have useful observations about how the candidates organise work. I would rather share those than turn a promotion into choosing the person I most enjoy lunch with. What would you ask before completing the form, without sounding opposed to the team having a say?

Discussion

5 community replies

Ask what decision the form informs and what criteria the manager wants you to consider. “I want to give useful input—are you asking for a preference, evidence against the role requirements or a final selection?” is a reasonable clarification before people treat the form as an election.

A colleague can be excellent company and still be untested at allocating work or giving feedback. Use examples you've actually observed, and be clear where you don't know. That is more useful than guessing who would be popular in charge.

It would also help to know whether comments or individual choices will be shared with candidates. Don't promise other colleagues that the form is anonymous when the invitation hasn't said so. Let the manager explain the process rather than building a private campaign around assumptions.

The team may have a better view of day-to-day leadership than a manager who only sees the polished updates. Reducing the exercise to management's criteria could lose that perspective.

Keep that perspective by giving specific examples and explaining what they show. The team having meaningful input doesn't require an unexplained name count. Ask for a route that preserves the observations while making clear who decides and how the competing requirements are weighed.

Join the discussion

More in Career / Work