Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Neighbours · Advice & Questions ·

We found old-looking coins in my neighbour's garden. Can I insist we ask about reporting now?

Neighbours category photographNeighbours

Two days ago my neighbour let me try his metal detector in his garden in England. We uncovered a small group of old-looking coins. Neither of us can identify them confidently.

He wants to get a dealer's estimate before contacting anyone official. He says there is no point making a fuss if they are worth very little. I would rather ask the local Finds Liaison Officer what we need to do now. GOV.UK's treasure guidance gives a 14-day reporting deadline from finding treasure or realising an item might be treasure; it doesn't say to wait for a price first.

I am not claiming these coins qualify, and I don't want to announce a treasure discovery to the street. But I helped find them and don't feel comfortable leaving the question unresolved while he shops around for an estimate. How should I handle this if he keeps asking me to wait?

Discussion

5 community replies

Ask the Finds Liaison Officer promptly and describe what you actually found. The uncertainty about whether the coins qualify is a reason to get guidance. A dealer's estimate wouldn't answer the reporting question for you.

I'd start with 'Can we contact them together today?' It lets him remain part of the find instead of feeling you have taken it over. Don't promise to keep waiting for a valuation if he declines.

The garden being his may make him feel that every decision is his. I would acknowledge that without pretending it settles the reporting position. Avoid dividing ownership or possible reward money between yourselves on the basis of guesses.

Perhaps offer to gather the details of when and where you found the coins while he makes the initial contact. That would give each of you something useful to do and make the next step less like one neighbour reporting the other.

That division could work if he actually contacts the officer promptly. I'd agree a time to do it together, rather than leave him an indefinite task. If he still refuses, explain that you will seek guidance about your own position as someone who helped make the find.

Join the discussion

More in Neighbours