Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Career / Work · Advice & Questions ·

We asked candidates for work samples, but the interview panel hasn’t read them

Career / Work category photographCareer / Work

The interview pack includes a short planning exercise we asked every candidate to prepare. Before the first interview, I discovered that two panel members hadn’t opened the submissions. One said we could ask candidates to explain everything live and see who sounded confident.

I’m the newest person on the panel. I don’t want to hold up a day people have cleared their diaries for, but we asked applicants to spend time on work we said would inform the discussion. If we rely on their presentation alone, I’m not sure why we asked them to submit it in advance.

Would you push for a pause before the interviews, or try to repair the process during them? I need a practical suggestion I can make in the room, not a speech about an ideal recruitment system we can’t build that morning.

Discussion

5 community replies

Start with the promise already made to candidates: “We said this work would inform the interview. Can we take a short review break and agree what we’re looking for before the first person comes in?” That is a concrete repair, not a demand to redesign the whole recruitment process.

Reading the samples and hearing someone explain them can do different jobs. The written piece shows choices the candidate prepared; the conversation can explore the reasoning and limits. Let the interview add to the submission rather than make the candidate recite it to people encountering it for the first time.

Can the chair assign each panel member specific aspects to review, with everyone still reading enough to understand the whole piece? That may make the available time useful. Avoid letting the only person who prepared become the unofficial scorer for every candidate without discussion.

A delay has a cost for candidates too, especially if they have arranged work or care around the slot. Pausing for panel preparation should not quietly mean leaving the first applicant waiting with no explanation.

Exactly. Check whether preparation can happen before the scheduled start or in an existing break. If a delay is unavoidable, have the chair communicate promptly and offer a workable adjustment. The panel should own the lapse; candidates should not have to rescue it by rushing or abandoning the interview time they were given.

Join the discussion

More in Career / Work