We agreed on no birthday gifts. I brought one anyway and enjoyed standing out
ConfessionsMy friend asked for a birthday dinner with food and no gifts. We all agreed. I arrived with food and a wrapped book.
She was delighted. Two guests started apologising for bringing nothing. One had specifically said in the group chat that no gifts was a relief.
I said it was "just a little thing". It was a good gift, and I'd also enjoyed imagining myself as the one who'd found something perfect.
Was the gift itself the mistake, or the public presentation? I don't want to ask my friend to enjoy it less. I want to be honest about why being the exception felt so good.