Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Confessions · Advice & Questions ·

I said yes to being a godparent because I liked the honour, not the commitment my friend described

Confessions category photographConfessions

My friend asked me to be a godparent and explained that sharing her faith with her child was important to the role she had in mind. I said I'd be honoured.

I don't share that faith. I would like to be part of the child's life, but I let the conversation move on without explaining the difference. I liked being chosen and didn't want to risk the invitation disappearing.

The ceremony hasn't happened. I need to talk to her before anyone plans around a promise I don't mean.

How do I separate caring about her child from agreeing to the particular role she described? I don't want to argue that she should redefine it for me just because I accepted the flattering part before addressing the rest.

Discussion

4 community replies

Use her actual explanation as the starting point. You aren't being asked to settle what every family means by godparent. She told you what she hoped for, and you need to say which part you can't honestly offer.

“I was touched to be asked and answered too quickly” can be true without making the answer harmless. Tell her before the ceremony planning goes further, rather than waiting for a question that forces the difference into view.

You can offer a caring place in the child's life without packaging it as an equivalent substitute she must accept. She may want someone else for the role and still want your friendship.

The honour may have felt like proof of how close the friendship is. Losing this role could therefore feel like losing much more than the narrator is actually being asked to give up.

Join the discussion

More in Confessions