Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Relationships · Advice & Questions ·

Was I wrong to share my grandmother's recipe when my aunt calls it a family secret?

Relationships category photographRelationships

I gave a friend the recipe for my grandmother's chilli paste after we cooked it together. My aunt heard and said I had given away something that belonged to the family.

Nobody had told me to keep it secret. I remember my grandmother showing neighbours how to make it, though my aunt says she would never have handed over the full written recipe. My friend has already made a batch and sent me a happy photograph.

For me, sharing it felt like keeping my grandmother present. For my aunt, it seems to have made something precious less ours. How do I talk about that without inventing a promise I never made or dismissing an attachment I didn't realise she had?

Discussion

5 community replies

Ask your aunt what she understood the agreement to be and how she learned it. You don't have to accept that you broke a promise to be interested in why she thinks there was one. Your different memories of your grandmother sharing the recipe matter too.

I'd acknowledge the attachment before debating the word secret. "I can see that this recipe feels like a special connection to her. Sharing it made me feel connected to her too." That explains your choice without treating your aunt's reaction as ridiculous.

Be careful about pulling your friend into the disagreement. She accepted a recipe you willingly gave her and has no reason to know about the family conversation. Don't ask her to perform guilt or pretend she never received it just to soothe the argument.

You could discuss how you want to pass the recipe on in future, including naming your grandmother and preserving the story behind it. That may matter to your aunt even if the two of you never agree that nobody outside the family should have it.

Giving the story a place could be a real offer, provided you mean it. It shouldn't become an indirect promise to keep the recipe private if that isn't what you're willing to agree to. Say which part of the request you can honestly honour.

Join the discussion

More in Relationships