Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Career / Work · Advice & Questions ·

The strongest applicant is being dismissed as too senior for the job

Career / Work category photographCareer / Work

I'm on a hiring panel for a coordinator vacancy. One applicant has previously managed a larger operation and is now applying for this hands-on role. Their examples were strong, and they said they wanted to spend more time doing the work and less time managing people.

After the interview, a panel member said we should reject them because they'd get bored and leave. We didn't ask what they understood about our routine tasks or whether the advertised salary suited them. We just seem to be treating their previous title as the answer.

I don't want us to ignore a genuine mismatch. I also don't think we learned enough to decide that someone with more experience can't mean what they said. How could I reopen this discussion fairly without giving one candidate a special chance to improve their interview?

Discussion

5 community replies

Ask the panel which requirement the applicant failed to meet and what evidence supports the concern. “They'll leave” is a prediction to examine, not a substitute for the criteria. If the interview left an important question unanswered, decide how to address that gap consistently for candidates still under consideration.

The routine work deserves an honest description. I'd want the candidate to understand the actual balance of coordination, administration and problem-solving. Their earlier management role doesn't tell you whether that balance is attractive to them now.

Check whether you're assuming they will demand authority they haven't asked for. At the same time, don't hire them on a secret plan to turn the vacancy into a management role. Evaluate the job you have, using what they said and demonstrated.

A follow-up about motivation could still let this applicant give the answer the panel wants. How would that be fair to someone who answered the original questions well?

Don't create a private rescue interview. Agree with the recruitment lead what clarification is genuinely needed, whether comparable candidates have the same gap and how answers will be assessed. You can challenge an unsupported assumption in the panel discussion even if no further candidate contact is appropriate.

Join the discussion

More in Career / Work