Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Politics · Advice & Questions ·

The room applauded a debate answer. Does that mean it answered the question?

Politics category photographPolitics

The question was which evening opening hours a public venue could keep. The answer was, "We can't afford everything." People applauded. I did too.

On the way home, my friend said that had settled the exchange. I realised I still didn't know which options the speaker had compared or what would be lost under each one. The line was a reasonable reminder about limits; it wasn't the information I'd been waiting for.

I don't want every lively answer reduced to a bureaucratic checklist. But I also don't want the response of the room to make an unanswered question disappear.

How would you assess that answer fairly, or ask a follow-up, without pretending that acknowledging a budget constraint was itself evasive?

Discussion

5 community replies

Write down the original question and what information the answer supplied. It acknowledged a limit but, from your account, didn't identify the opening-hours options. You can recognise the first point and still ask for the second.

Applause tells you the line landed with people in the room. It doesn't add details to the answer. Your own reaction is a useful reminder that a satisfying moment and a complete explanation can be different experiences.

The constraint may matter a great deal. A follow-up should give the speaker room to explain it, rather than assume there must be an easy way to keep every hour people want.

You may not get every comparison explained during a short debate. Asking one focused follow-up or where the details can be found might be more productive than insisting on a complete assessment there and then.

That fits this gap. Ask which opening-hours alternatives were considered and where their implications are set out. If there isn't time to explain them on stage, a specific route to that information would still move the question forward.

Join the discussion

More in Politics