The room applauded a debate answer. Does that mean it answered the question?
PoliticsThe question was which evening opening hours a public venue could keep. The answer was, "We can't afford everything." People applauded. I did too.
On the way home, my friend said that had settled the exchange. I realised I still didn't know which options the speaker had compared or what would be lost under each one. The line was a reasonable reminder about limits; it wasn't the information I'd been waiting for.
I don't want every lively answer reduced to a bureaucratic checklist. But I also don't want the response of the room to make an unanswered question disappear.
How would you assess that answer fairly, or ask a follow-up, without pretending that acknowledging a budget constraint was itself evasive?