Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Career / Work · Advice & Questions ·

The recruiter wants my current manager's reference before choosing a finalist

Career / Work category photographCareer / Work

The recruiter has asked for my current manager's contact details before the hiring team chooses between two finalists. I'm applying for a job in England, and there isn't an offer yet.

My manager doesn't know I'm looking. We work well together, but telling her now would change our conversations about next year's projects, and I might not get this job. I can provide a previous manager as a reference, although they wouldn't know my most recent work.

The recruiter says they won't say anything negative and that early references make the process faster. That doesn't remove the fact that they'd be announcing my job search. How should I ask them to delay contact with my current employer, and what alternative would let them keep making a proper decision about my application?

Discussion

5 community replies

Be explicit that you have not agreed to contact with your current employer. Acas guidance on references says a recruiting employer should have made a conditional offer and obtained the applicant's permission before approaching their current employer. You can cite that as good practice while asking the recruiter to confirm the timing they will use.

Offer the previous manager now, with their permission, and explain what period and responsibilities they can cover. Ask whether the current reference can be a later condition if you're selected. That gives the recruiter a concrete alternative rather than leaving the request unanswered.

I'd separate speed from the risk you're being asked to accept. A pleasant reference conversation still tells your manager you're applying elsewhere. You don't need to claim she'd punish you; preserving control over when she learns about the search is enough to explain the concern.

What if the recruiter says the process is identical for both finalists and cannot be changed? Declining could cost you a job you want.

It could, so ask whether that is actually a firm requirement or simply their usual sequence. If they insist, you have a real choice about whether to proceed on those terms. Don't quietly supply the contact details while hoping “not yet” will be understood; get a clear answer before they make contact.

Join the discussion

More in Career / Work