Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Politics · Advice & Questions ·

The real decisions seem to happen in the pub after our civic meetings

Politics category photographPolitics

The meeting ended with two options still open. I left to catch the last bus. At the next meeting, the agenda had moved straight to implementing one of them.

Several regulars had carried on talking in the pub afterwards. One told me they'd worked it out there and thought everyone would be pleased to avoid another long discussion. I don't know whether they believed they were making a decision or simply developing a proposal.

I like that people care enough to continue talking. I don't want to police friendships or insist every idea must originate under the fluorescent lights in the hall. But people who can't stay late should still be part of the group's decisions.

How should I raise the gap between a useful informal conversation and an agreement the whole association is being asked to act on?

Discussion

5 community replies

Ask when and through what process the option was adopted. Keep that question separate from whether you like it. The agenda may be overstating a conversation that its participants only meant as a proposal.

I'd ask for the options to return to the proper meeting with enough information to discuss them. The pub conversation can contribute reasoning; it shouldn't quietly supply authority the group's process hasn't given it.

Explain the practical barrier rather than assume a deliberate effort to exclude you. Catching the last bus is enough to show why attendance after the meeting can't be treated as part of the meeting everyone agreed to attend.

Please don't demand a transcript of every informal exchange. People need somewhere to try out half-formed ideas without producing official minutes.

The useful requirement is that a proposal and its reasons reach the people who will decide it. That doesn't require recording every conversation. It does require presenting an idea as an idea until the authorised decision has actually happened.

Join the discussion

More in Politics