Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Politics · Advice & Questions ·

The council published a scanned table. How do I ask for figures people can actually use?

Politics category photographPolitics

The figures are online, but the table is a scan of a large printed page. I can read it when I zoom in. I can't search the entries or reliably line them up beside another year without copying them out.

I'm helping a civic group understand the public spending papers. Someone said that asking for a different format was moving the goalposts: we'd wanted publication, and the council had published them. An officer also pointed out that the staff might not hold the original spreadsheet.

I don't want to assume they can produce any file I imagine. I do want to explain why availability and practical use are different questions.

What would be a reasonable request, and how can we keep any comparisons honest if we have to transcribe the figures ourselves?

Discussion

5 community replies

Describe the task you're trying to do and the obstacle: comparing the same entries across years without manual copying. Then ask what existing digital versions are held and whether one can be provided. That gives the request a purpose without inventing a file they must have.

If you transcribe the table, keep the original alongside it and check the entries before circulating calculations. Mark your transcription as your work so a copying error doesn't silently become a claim about the council's published figure.

The officer's point matters. A scan might be all that survives in the material they received. You can ask about the source and the available formats without assuming the absence of a convenient spreadsheet proves obstruction.

For the next publication, a practical example could help more than a general complaint that the format is bad. Show one comparison the group is trying to make and where the scan makes it difficult.

That would make the request easier to assess. Explain the repeated task, ask what can reasonably be supplied now, and suggest a usable format for future releases. You can acknowledge that publication was useful while still asking how the information could become easier to work with.

Join the discussion

More in Politics