Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Politics · Advice & Questions ·

The council answered our request and rejected it. Is it fair to say we were ignored?

Politics category photographPolitics

Our group asked for another weekly market day. The council's reply discusses the location, staffing, and disturbance concerns we raised, then explains why it favours the current arrangement.

I disagree with parts of the reasoning. Another member wants our response headed "Council ignores residents again." When I objected, she said receiving a polite letter wasn't the same as being heard.

I agree with that distinction. A personalised reply can still miss the substance. But getting the answer we wanted doesn't seem to be the only possible evidence that someone considered the request.

How should we judge the reply and describe what remains unresolved? I want to challenge a weak answer without using "ignored" simply to mean "didn't agree with us."

Discussion

5 community replies

Compare your actual requests with the reasons in the reply. Which concerns were addressed, which were misunderstood, and which were left out? That will give the next letter more substance than a verdict about whether the tone was polite.

Being considered doesn't guarantee agreement. Equally, naming an issue in a reply doesn't prove it was examined adequately. You can recognise the response and still question the evidence behind it.

I'd quote the particular reason you dispute and explain the gap. If the council thinks disturbance rules out another day, for example, ask what options or evidence its account considered rather than claim it never responded.

Your fellow member may mean that the process gave residents no real opportunity to affect the decision. That's worth asking about separately from whether this letter mentions the points you made.

Ask her to identify that concern clearly. The group could challenge a closed process, a missing assessment, or a weak reason, but those are different claims. Describe the one the evidence supports and keep the request for a better answer focused on it.

Join the discussion

More in Politics