Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Career / Work · Advice & Questions ·

The client chose the design I nearly left out of the presentation

Career / Work category photographCareer / Work

I showed the client three approaches for a printed welcome pack. They chose the quietest one—the version I had almost removed because I thought it was too familiar.

They explained that it looked like something their staff would actually use. My preferred version is more distinctive, and I can imagine it looking better in my portfolio. I haven't identified a clear error in the version they selected.

I am the designer they hired for judgment, so I don't want to become someone who simply nods at every choice. I also suspect I'm treating their preference as a problem because it isn't mine. When is another challenge useful, and when should I commit to making the chosen direction work?

Discussion

5 community replies

Their explanation gives you a criterion to work with: staff use. Ask what features made this version feel right, then develop those deliberately. That could be more useful than trying to reopen the vote until they choose your favourite.

Including an option in the presentation signals that you consider it viable. If it met the brief, the client choosing it isn't necessarily a failure of your advice. It may reveal that their priorities differ from what you expected.

There is room to say, “Before I develop this, one trade-off is…” if you can name a concrete concern. Keep that separate from the fact that another direction would make a more striking portfolio piece. Your own preference can be real without becoming the client's problem.

The client may not recognise a weak choice until it is printed. Isn't warning them part of why they hired a designer?

Yes, if you have a specific weakness to explain. Identify the consequence and offer a way to address it within the chosen direction where possible. If the remaining disagreement is taste, describe it honestly rather than recasting your preference as an objective defect.

Join the discussion

More in Career / Work