The client chose the design I nearly left out of the presentation
Career / WorkI showed the client three approaches for a printed welcome pack. They chose the quietest one—the version I had almost removed because I thought it was too familiar.
They explained that it looked like something their staff would actually use. My preferred version is more distinctive, and I can imagine it looking better in my portfolio. I haven't identified a clear error in the version they selected.
I am the designer they hired for judgment, so I don't want to become someone who simply nods at every choice. I also suspect I'm treating their preference as a problem because it isn't mine. When is another challenge useful, and when should I commit to making the chosen direction work?