Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Politics · Advice & Questions ·

Should we recreate an angry exchange for a photograph in our civic newsletter?

Politics category photographPolitics

After a lively but civil discussion about a local proposal, the person taking photos for our civic newsletter asked two members to stand up, point at each other and look cross. They said a picture of people quietly listening wouldn't show how much the issue mattered.

The two members had disagreed, but they hadn't pointed or shouted. One laughed at the request; the other said it would make the meeting look hostile. We still need a picture for the newsletter. Is there a reasonable way to pose one without making a scene that never happened look like evidence of the discussion?

Discussion

5 community replies

Pose a straightforward group picture if you need one. You don't need to manufacture anger to show that people cared.

The member who laughed may not mind acting it out. The problem is what readers will understand from the photograph, especially beside an account of a real disagreement.

A photograph of someone listening can suit a civic discussion perfectly well. I'd ask what the article needs to communicate before deciding the image has to look dramatic.

What if the caption clearly says the picture is staged? That could make it an illustration rather than a misleading record.

A prominent caption would change how it's presented, but the members can still decline that portrayal. For this newsletter, I'd choose a calmer posed image that doesn't need an explanation to undo a false impression of the meeting.

Join the discussion

More in Politics