Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Politics · Advice & Questions ·

Should the person who made a complaint help decide our civic group's response?

Politics category photographPolitics

A committee member has complained about another member's conduct at our residents' association meeting. She is also on the rota for the small panel that would consider the complaint. She says stepping aside would deprive the panel of the person who best understands what happened.

I can see why her account matters. I'm less comfortable with her helping decide what to accept in a dispute where her own account is being questioned. We have few volunteers, and replacing everyone who knows either person would be difficult.

Would you separate giving an account from taking part in the decision, even if that means finding another willing panel member and delaying the response? We need to check our association's procedure, but I'd like a fair principle to propose rather than simply choosing which person I trust.

Discussion

5 community replies

Her account can be heard without making her one of the people deciding the outcome. I'd start by asking whether your procedure allows those two roles to be separated.

I'd want the person complained about to understand who will decide and have a chance to answer the actual complaint. Otherwise a change of panel member alone might not address the concern.

A delay has a cost for both people. If you need a substitute, explain what is being arranged and when you'll update them instead of leaving the complaint in an indefinite pause.

If knowing the participants disqualifies everyone, a small association may never find a panel. I wouldn't treat ordinary acquaintance as the same problem as being the complainant.

That distinction helps. You could look for someone who knows the group but hasn't made the complaint or become part of the disputed events. Any substitute still needs to fit the agreed procedure; being from outside isn't automatically a solution either.

Join the discussion

More in Politics