Should the oldest clubs keep first choice of our meeting room forever?
PoliticsOur residents' association owns a room with very few evening slots. The same clubs have used the popular ones for years, and the proposed booking policy would let existing users renew those slots before anyone else can apply. There is no end date to that priority.
I can see why the clubs want continuity. They've built their activities around those evenings, and some members organise lifts or care arrangements to attend. But a new civic discussion group has been waiting for a usable slot, and it is hard to call the room open to everyone if every convenient evening is always renewed first.
I'm tempted to support one more renewal for existing groups, followed by a different allocation process. Another committee member thinks even that would break faith with people who helped make the room useful. We still need to check what was actually promised to existing users before we settle anything.
How much weight should years of using a shared resource carry when we write a new rule? What would a fair transition look like for both established groups and people who have never had a chance to book?