Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Politics · Advice & Questions ·

Should people who work on our high street get a speaking slot if they live elsewhere?

Politics category photographPolitics

Our residents' association is holding an open discussion about the high street. A shop worker asked to speak about the timing of deliveries, but a member said the microphone should be reserved for people who live inside our boundary. The worker spends most weekdays there but rents a home in another neighbourhood.

Our association's membership votes are for eligible members under our own rules. This event is a discussion, with no formal vote, and the invitation says 'open meeting'. We only have an hour, so hearing everyone at length isn't possible.

I'd like to hear from people affected by the street as well as residents. Others worry that opening the queue will leave the association's members with less time. What is a fair way to decide who speaks without pretending that everyone who contributes has the same role in our association?

Discussion

5 community replies

The distinction between speaking and voting seems useful here. You can hear a worker's account without making them a member or changing who takes the association's decisions.

An open invitation followed by a residents-only microphone would be frustrating. If that's the intended limit, it should have been stated before people decided whether to attend.

Residents also need a real chance to speak. I'd use short contributions and make room for different connections to the street, rather than let a string of people from any one group take the whole hour.

With just an hour, written input feels like a reasonable compromise for the worker. Delivery details might be easier to circulate on paper anyway.

Only if written input is a meaningful option for everyone. Sending the worker to paper while residents get heard in the room would recreate the same hierarchy. A written route can supplement a short speaking slot, especially for delivery details that need careful explanation.

Join the discussion

More in Politics