Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Politics · Advice & Questions ·

Should only homeowners be eligible to chair our neighbourhood forum?

Politics category photographPolitics

A member who rents locally wants to stand for chair of our voluntary neighbourhood forum. Some owner members want a new rule limiting the role to homeowners because they think ownership shows a lasting stake in the area.

The forum discusses local services; it doesn't manage anyone's lease or building. Renters are already full voting members. The proposed candidate says she's willing to serve the full term and prepare a handover, but supporters of the restriction worry that a move could leave the forum looking for another chair.

I think we should ask every candidate about availability and continuity rather than use housing tenure as a shortcut. Am I underestimating the value of a long-term connection? How would you assess that connection without assuming a homeowner will stay or a renter will leave?

Discussion

5 community replies

If renters are full members, I'd want a clear explanation of why they can choose the chair but cannot be considered for the role. A possible future move doesn't answer that on its own.

The concern about continuity is understandable. I'd ask all candidates what they can commit to, what might interrupt the term, and how they'd hand work over. Those answers seem more relevant than a category on a form.

What does the chair actually need to do? Knowledge of local services, willingness to listen and time for the work would be higher on my list than owning a home.

I'd be particularly uncomfortable if the rules are changing because this specific person wants to stand. Whatever the qualification is, candidates should know it before deciding to put themselves forward.

Yes. I'd separate a general review of eligibility from judging this candidate. If a new restriction is proposed now, the forum should explain both its purpose and why it needs to affect the current process, rather than quietly moving the line around one person.

Join the discussion

More in Politics