Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Politics · Advice & Questions ·

Should online members keep their cameras on throughout our association meeting?

Politics category photographPolitics

Our residents' association chair wants everyone joining online to keep a camera on for the whole meeting, including discussion before a vote. She says she needs to know who is still present and participating.

A member who shares a room with family is willing to speak and answer when called, but doesn't want to send a continuous view of the room into the meeting. The chair sees exceptions as hard to apply fairly. Some people attending in the hall also think visible attendance should mean the same thing for everyone.

Could we agree a way to confirm identity and participation without requiring continuous video, or is the camera rule a reasonable condition for taking part remotely? I'd like us to name the actual concern before choosing the rule, rather than treating a dark square as proof someone has stopped caring.

Discussion

5 community replies

Is the concern identifying the member, knowing they're present for a vote, or seeing whether they're listening throughout? Those are different problems. A camera rule could be doing several jobs badly because nobody has chosen the main one.

I'd ask whether an agreed name check when a decision is taken would address the presence concern under your association's rules. That is something to discuss, not a guarantee that it solves every identity question.

The shared room is a concrete constraint, not just a preference for hiding. I would want to understand what that person can reasonably do before writing a condition they can't meet.

I can see why people in the hall resent different expectations. They have made the trip and are visibly there; remote members shouldn't be able to disappear until the final vote and expect that to count as full participation.

That concern deserves an attendance standard, but continuous home video isn't the only possible standard to discuss. You could agree when everyone needs to be available and how absence is recorded, then check whether the proposed arrangements work for both groups.

Join the discussion

More in Politics