Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Politics · Advice & Questions ·

Should new civic-association members have to wait before they can vote?

Politics category photographPolitics

Our association is considering a waiting period before new members can vote on its plans. Supporters say it would give people time to understand the work and prevent sudden changes by people who join for a single decision. Newer members say they already live with the consequences and shouldn’t have to earn a voice through months of attendance.

I joined recently, so I would be affected. I can also see why long-standing volunteers worry about the group’s direction changing without much discussion. We haven’t established what problem has actually occurred or how the proposed period would address it.

What should we examine before adopting any rule? I want a stable association, but not one where established members can indefinitely decide when newcomers are ready to count.

Discussion

5 community replies

Ask for the problem and the purpose before choosing a waiting period. Induction, eligibility and preventing a decision from being rushed are different needs; one restriction may not address them all.

Whatever the group proposes, check its existing governing arrangements and how a change can be agreed. Don’t invent a new eligibility condition in the middle of a contested vote.

A newcomer can bring relevant local knowledge without knowing the filing system or committee history. If orientation is the concern, offer that knowledge rather than treating time served as a complete substitute.

People who have sustained the group may feel they could lose control of work they will still be expected to carry out.

That is a serious workload concern to discuss directly. Clarify what a proposed decision would require and who could deliver it. A voting restriction should not quietly become a way to avoid hearing newer members’ concerns about that work.

Join the discussion

More in Politics