Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Relationships · Advice & Questions ·

Should I tell a friend we've been making jokes about her when she wasn't there?

Relationships category photographRelationships

Our group has a running joke about how one friend organises everything. I've laughed at impressions of her reminders and added a couple of my own. Last weekend she arrived with a careful plan for a picnic, and I felt ashamed because we were quietly grateful for the work we'd been mocking.

She makes jokes about her own lists sometimes. That had become my excuse for treating the private version as harmless. She hasn't heard most of it, and I don't think she'd enjoy being the subject of a whole conversation while absent.

Do I tell her and apologise, or would that mainly unload my guilt onto someone who wasn't hurt before I spoke? I know I need to stop joining in. I don't know what honesty requires beyond that, especially if she later hears about it from someone else.

Discussion

5 community replies

Stopping your own contribution is the first change you can make without asking her to do anything. You can also say to the group that the joke has become unfair, particularly when everyone benefits from the organising. Don't make an apology to her a substitute for changing those conversations.

Consider what information would help her make choices about the friendship, not only what would make you feel less guilty. She may deserve an honest account of a repeated pattern. That doesn't mean she needs every imitation replayed for her in order to receive an apology.

Her jokes about her own lists aren't the same as agreement to be discussed while absent. You can acknowledge that distinction without deciding everyone intended cruelty. Sometimes the useful admission is that you kept going because the excuse was comfortable for you.

If you speak to her, own what you did rather than presenting a report in which the others were worse. "I joined in jokes about your reminders, and I regret it" gives her a clear account of your part. Then let her decide what she wants to ask.

Answer those questions honestly without trying to control how quickly she reassures you. She may find the pattern more serious than you hoped, or less. The point of telling her should be respect for her, not obtaining a particular response that makes the confession feel worthwhile.

Join the discussion

More in Relationships