Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Politics · Advice & Questions ·

Should I take a Scottish education-policy question to my MP because Westminster is 'more senior'?

Politics category photographPolitics

My sister wants to ask about a proposed change to education policy in Scotland. I suggested contacting an MSP. A friend said we should go straight to the Westminster MP because that is the more senior office and the question would carry more weight.

The Scottish Parliament's guide to MSPs lists education and training among devolved matters for which an MSP can offer support, and distinguishes these from reserved matters handled by MPs. That makes me think responsibility is a better starting point than a ladder of political importance.

This is a question about the policy, rather than a request to overturn an individual school's decision. I don't want to promise that any representative can deliver the answer we want. How would you explain the choice of office without making it sound as though we're dismissing the MP?

Discussion

5 community replies

I'd say, 'Let's start with the representative whose parliament deals with this policy.' That explains the route without comparing the people. You can still value an MP's work while recognising that this question belongs elsewhere.

The friend's suggestion may come from wanting the concern taken seriously. Acknowledge that aim before correcting the route. Otherwise a useful explanation of devolution could turn into an argument about whether the family is being ambitious enough.

Make the requested answer specific: which part of the education proposal worries your sister, and what does she want clarified? Even the right office will struggle with a message that only says the whole system needs fixing.

Copying both offices would be my default if I couldn't tell who held the policy responsibility. Asking for direction seems better than abandoning the enquiry.

If the boundary really is unclear, that makes sense. Here the question is expressly about Scottish education policy, so I'd start with the MSP route and say so. Sending it everywhere without explanation could create extra correspondence rather than a clearer answer.

Join the discussion

More in Politics