Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Neighbours · Advice & Questions ·

Should I serve donated yoghurts past their use-by date because the pots are sealed?

Neighbours category photographNeighbours

A neighbour in England brought yoghurts for a shared lunch. The pots are sealed, but their use-by date was the previous day. She says they have stayed in her fridge, haven't been frozen and will be fine if they smell normal.

They haven't been put out or eaten. I offered to help with the lunch and don't want to serve them on that assurance. The Food Standards Agency's food-safety guide says use-by dates concern safety and that appearance or smell cannot establish safety after that date.

She feels I am dismissing a useful donation and encouraging waste. How can I decline these items while keeping future offers welcome? I don't want one conversation to turn into a public judgment about everything she keeps in her fridge.

Discussion

5 community replies

Keep the yoghurts out of the lunch and explain the use-by point directly. The sealed lids and a normal smell don't answer the guidance you have cited.

Her wish to avoid waste is understandable. For a later lunch, an earlier handover and an agreed check of dates could help prevent the same disappointment. That doesn't make this batch suitable now.

You have already established that the label says use-by. There is no need to argue about every food carrying a best-before date; that would answer a different question.

I'd begin with a private word rather than a group announcement about her donations. The immediate issue can be resolved by not serving these pots.

Agreed. Tell her which items you aren't using and why, and thank her for offering to contribute. You can keep the decision clear without asking for an account of her whole household's food habits.

Join the discussion

More in Neighbours