Should I keep a surprise-party secret after learning the neighbour doesn't want a party?
Neighbours“She always says that because she's modest,” the organiser replied when I mentioned what our neighbour had told me.
Our neighbour had been clear over coffee: she wanted a quiet birthday, with no party, not even a small one. I learned that after agreeing to keep the organiser's surprise plan secret. Other neighbours are now offering to cook and bring chairs.
I don't want to spoil something people are working on kindly. I am also uncomfortable helping arrange the exact sort of gathering she asked not to have.
Should I first ask the organiser to change the plan, and tell the neighbour if she won't? I would prefer the organising effort to change direction without an argument, but I don't want a promise about secrecy to make the recipient's stated preference disappear.