Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Food · Advice & Questions ·

Should I change my bread dough because the slice was gummy while the loaf was still hot?

Food category photographFood

The crust was crisp and I wanted a slice immediately, so I cut the loaf while steam was still escaping. The knife dragged through the middle and the slice felt gummy. My first reaction was to put less water in the next dough.

I used a no-knead recipe whose baking notes specifically warn against slicing this loaf hot. I'd read the oven stage closely and skimmed the cooling part.

Would you repeat the recipe, including its doneness checks and cooling directions, before changing the dough? I can't tell from this slice alone whether cooling was the whole problem. I'd like the next attempt to answer that more clearly.

Discussion

5 community replies

Yes. Keep the dough quantities steady and follow the complete baking and cooling method next time. The linked recipe identifies hot slicing as a cause of gumminess; it doesn't prove that every gummy loaf is fully baked.

Put cooling into the dinner plan. 'Out of the oven when we sit down' may be the wrong target.

Don't use this one slice to diagnose every stage of the recipe. Record what you actually checked before taking the loaf out, as well as when you cut it. Those are two separate pieces of information.

Could you bake earlier and serve the bread later? That might work better than trying to build enough willpower to ignore a hot loaf.

That is the change I'd make too. Decide when you want to eat it, then work backwards through the recipe's rise, bake and cooling stages. The waiting becomes part of making the bread rather than an unexplained delay after you think you're done.

Join the discussion

More in Food