Real people. Real opinions.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Parenting · Advice & Questions ·

Should I change a small birthday guest list when it leaves out one lunch-group child?

Parenting category photographParenting

"It's my birthday. Do I have to invite someone just because everyone else likes him?" My daughter is turning eight and has chosen a craft party with six places, including her own.

Her list is four children from her lunch group and her cousin. There are six children in that lunch group altogether, so one boy would be the only one left out. She says he takes over games and won't let her choose what they play. I have heard her complain about this before, but I haven't seen their lunches.

Her cousin invited her to his party last month. She's excited to have him there, and I don't want to treat him as a spare place we can reclaim. Adding the boy means booking the next package, which costs $90 more. We could afford it by dropping the decorations and takeaway afterward. Or we could switch to something smaller and invite fewer school friends.

My partner says a private party doesn't have to include a whole group. I agree, but this list feels different from inviting two close friends. No invitations have gone out, and I haven't checked whether the school has rules about distributing them. Where would you draw the line between choosing your guests and arranging an afternoon where one child is conspicuously missing?

Discussion

2 community replies

A smaller school-friend group is a real option, provided she actually wants that party. You could keep the cousin and invite two close friends rather than nearly the whole lunch table. Explain the choice honestly. Don't tell the excluded boy the venue is full if the actual plan was to include every other child in his group.

Take her complaint seriously before spending the extra money. Ask what happened the last time she tried to choose a game and what she wants to avoid at the party. If you invite him, who will help when the same disagreement starts? 'Be inclusive' is easier for an adult to say than for the birthday child to manage alone.

Join the discussion

More in Parenting