Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Neighbours · Advice & Questions ·

Should I challenge a plan to give our grieving neighbour a surprise kitten?

Neighbours category photographNeighbours

Our neighbour's cat died recently. A few people are putting together a care package, and I offered to contribute towards it. The organiser has now suggested using the money to get her a kitten and surprising her at the door.

I knew we were buying a comforting gift. I hadn't agreed to contribute towards a pet, and nobody has asked her whether she wants another cat. The organiser says asking would spoil the kindness and that she has always been a cat person.

Nothing has been bought or reserved yet. I would happily contribute to something she chooses, or to ordinary help while she is upset. How do I ask the group to stop the surprise-pet plan without claiming to know what our neighbour wants either? I don't want my objection to become another group deciding what her grief ought to look like.

Discussion

5 community replies

Ask them to check with her before committing to a kitten. You don't need to know that she would refuse. The missing information is whether she wants one, and she is the person who can answer.

I'd separate your contribution from the organiser's new idea. You offered money towards a care package; tell them that offer doesn't extend to buying a pet without her agreement. You can still support a gift she actually wants.

The surprise seems to have become more important than the recipient's choice. You could preserve a small surprise with flowers or a note while asking her directly about any larger offer. Those are different decisions.

Would asking whether she'd like help finding another cat still put pressure on her to consider it before she's ready? I'd start by asking what would be useful now, rather than presenting a pet as the expected next step.

That's a fair caution. An open offer of company or practical help lets her set the direction. If she brings up wanting another cat, the group can ask whether she wants help then. There is no need to make adopting again the measure of whether the care package succeeded.

Join the discussion

More in Neighbours