Should I challenge a plan to give our grieving neighbour a surprise kitten?
NeighboursOur neighbour's cat died recently. A few people are putting together a care package, and I offered to contribute towards it. The organiser has now suggested using the money to get her a kitten and surprising her at the door.
I knew we were buying a comforting gift. I hadn't agreed to contribute towards a pet, and nobody has asked her whether she wants another cat. The organiser says asking would spoil the kindness and that she has always been a cat person.
Nothing has been bought or reserved yet. I would happily contribute to something she chooses, or to ordinary help while she is upset. How do I ask the group to stop the surprise-pet plan without claiming to know what our neighbour wants either? I don't want my objection to become another group deciding what her grief ought to look like.