Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Funny · Advice & Questions ·

Should I ask to swap back two gifts after my friend loves the present meant for Mum?

Funny category photographFunny

'You remembered I needed these,' my friend said, holding up the hedgehog oven mitts.

I had remembered that Mum wanted them. My friend's present was a pencil case wrapped in the same paper. I put the wrong name cards on the parcels.

My friend has opened hers and likes it. Mum hasn't opened the other parcel yet. I can correct the mix-up now, but I don't want to announce that the thoughtful present my friend is enjoying was selected for somebody else and then immediately take it away.

I'm happy to discuss another plan with Mum if that works for everyone. Do I explain the mistake and offer a swap, or let my friend keep the mitts and arrange Mum's present separately?

Discussion

5 community replies

Explain the mix-up before asking for anything back. If you're genuinely happy for your friend to keep the mitts, say that clearly. Otherwise the explanation could sound like a polite request to surrender something she has already enjoyed receiving.

Tell Mum that the parcels were mixed before she opens the pencil case and tries to interpret it as a carefully chosen gift. She can be part of deciding the next step rather than finding out after you have made another plan on her behalf.

Your friend's pleasure can be genuine even though your intended recipient was different. Don't correct her enjoyment. Correct the account of how the parcel reached her, then discuss what each person would prefer.

Decide what you are actually asking before contacting her: do you need to exchange the presents, or mainly want to stop pretending the choice was intentional? Those are different conversations. A vague disclosure can leave her trying to guess whether she is expected to return the mitts.

If a swap matters, ask directly and hear her answer. If keeping them is fine, make that part unambiguous and work out Mum's gift with Mum. You don't need a second round of mysterious parcel decisions to repair the first one.

Join the discussion

More in Funny