Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Funny · Advice & Questions ·

Should I admit I changed a crossword clue before returning my friend's test copy?

Funny category photographFunny

My friend's crossword now contains a clue she didn't write. Unfortunately, that clue is in my handwriting.

She asked me to try the puzzle before she shared it with friends. I got stuck, thought of wording I found clearer, and crossed out her clue to put mine above it. Now my notes don't distinguish between what I solved and what I rewrote.

I wanted to be helpful. I also didn't want to return the sheet with a large blank patch, as though I'd given up on her work.

What should I tell her when I hand it back? I'd like to be an honest test solver rather than an uninvited second crossword setter.

Discussion

5 community replies

Explain the alteration before she reads the sheet: 'I got stuck here and changed the wording. That isn't a record of solving your original clue.' Keep the crossed-out version visible so she can see what happened.

The blank patch would have been information, not an insult. Your friend can use an account of where you stopped; she can't tell that from a sheet which quietly substitutes a different task.

'Try it' could mean several kinds of help. Ask whether she wanted solving notes, suggested edits or both, but don't treat that ambiguity as permission you had already established.

Your difficulty can be useful feedback even if she chooses to keep the clue. You don't need to prove your wording is the correct version before you can describe what held you up.

That leaves the decision with the person making the puzzle. Say where you got stuck and offer your alternative as an alternative; she can consider it without mistaking it for the original test result.

Join the discussion

More in Funny