Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Neighbours · Advice & Questions ·

Should everyone have to bring something to a neighbours' swap?

Neighbours category photographNeighbours

Our poster says, “Bring what you don't need; take what you can use.” A volunteer now wants to refuse entry to anyone arriving empty-handed.

I helped arrange the swap and wrote the poster. One neighbour asked whether she could come after having already cleared out her cupboards. I said yes. The volunteer thinks that is unfair to people supplying the items.

We never agreed a one-for-one exchange. We also haven't discussed what happens if someone wants to take a large amount. The event hasn't opened, so there is time to make the arrangement clear.

Should we keep this one open to people without items and consider different rules for another event? I want to respect the contributions without surprising someone at the door with a condition I already told her didn't apply.

Discussion

5 community replies

Start with the invitation and the answer you gave. Changing the admission condition now needs an explicit discussion and clear communication; it shouldn't happen through one volunteer turning people away.

Ask what problem the proposed rule is meant to solve. Lack of items, one person taking too much and a preference for equal exchanges would call for different arrangements.

Acknowledge that people supplying things want them used fairly. You can value that contribution without assuming every recipient must currently have something suitable to bring.

Could a limit on how much each person takes address the worry while keeping the event open? That seems more closely related to one person clearing a table.

It might, if the organisers agree and explain it before people start choosing. Don't present that as a solution to a problem you've already proved exists; it is an option for managing the event fairly.

Join the discussion

More in Neighbours