Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Politics · Advice & Questions ·

Should every spending decision in our civic group need a two-thirds vote?

Politics category photographPolitics

Our civic association is considering a rule requiring two-thirds of votes cast for every spending proposal. Supporters want to stop a narrow majority committing everyone's subscriptions to activities the rest dislike.

I understand the concern. But the proposed wording would cover routine purchases as well as major new commitments. Even after agreeing a yearly activity plan, we could need another two-thirds vote to buy the materials for it. The organisers think that would make ordinary work exhausting; supporters say convenience is how financial control slips away.

Would you apply the higher threshold to everything, or distinguish major commitments from spending within an agreed plan? I'm trying to find a rule that protects members without making a fresh constitutional argument out of every receipt.

Discussion

5 community replies

A stronger threshold might make sense for commitments that are expensive to reverse. I'd want to know what sort of disputed purchase prompted this proposal before deciding that every item needs the same treatment.

Does approving the annual plan currently authorise any spending, or only describe activities? Make that explicit. Otherwise members could believe they've agreed a budget while organisers think they've only agreed an idea.

Try the wording against last year's actual decisions before adopting it. Seeing which purchases would have needed another vote could reveal an inconvenience or a loophole that neither side has noticed.

I'd worry about splitting one unpopular project into several small purchases. An exception for routine items could swallow the protection if the definition is loose.

Then the exception needs an agreed overall limit and a clear purpose, rather than permission for unlimited small items. Reporting the combined spending would also matter. Your concern is a reason to test the boundary, not assume every purchase has to be settled in the same way.

Join the discussion

More in Politics