Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Politics · Advice & Questions ·

Should doing more volunteer hours give a member more votes in our civic association?

Politics category photographPolitics

A long-serving volunteer has proposed that members of our civic association get extra votes according to the hours they work for it. They spend evenings organising events and feel outvoted by people who appear only for decisions. I understand the resentment when someone else's plan becomes their workload.

But some members can offer time only irregularly, and some of the work happens quietly between meetings. We don't even record hours consistently. I'd rather give project volunteers a real say over what they can commit to delivering than make every association decision depend on a timesheet.

Would extra voting weight fairly recognise the work, or turn availability into permanent influence? This would be a change to our own association's arrangements, which would need to follow our existing rules; it isn't a claim about how public elections should work.

Discussion

5 community replies

The workload problem is real. Start by making clear that a vote for a project doesn't commit named volunteers to unlimited work. A willing group decision still needs willing people to deliver it.

I'd keep membership votes separate from hours. Recognise the work through support, realistic project limits and shared tasks rather than making a busy member's voice worth less.

Even a carefully recorded hour isn't a complete measure of contribution. A short task using a particular skill may be valuable, and someone keeping records could spend longer than the person doing the task.

What if the extra vote were capped? That would recognise commitment without letting one organiser dominate everything.

A cap would limit the size of the advantage, but it wouldn't answer why available time should determine voting weight. Discuss that principle before designing the formula. The organiser's need for control over their own workload deserves a more direct answer too.

Join the discussion

More in Politics