Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Politics · Advice & Questions ·

Should audience votes decide every question asked at our civic forum?

Politics category photographPolitics

We're planning a civic forum where the audience can vote for submitted questions. The most supported questions would be read first. One organiser wants that ranking to decide the entire programme, saying it would keep the moderator's preferences out of it.

I like giving the audience a say. But we may hear several versions of one popular topic and never reach a less popular question about how the proposal's maintenance costs would be reviewed. We only have time for a few questions, so no arrangement will include everything.

Would you reserve some slots for relevant questions that the ranking misses, or would that break the promise of an audience-led forum? We can still explain the selection method before anyone submits or votes.

Discussion

5 community replies

If you want some moderator-selected questions, say that from the start. Don't advertise that the ranking decides everything and then quietly replace it when the results aren't what you expected.

I'd use the votes as one input. Hearing the most requested topic matters, but a programme can also make room for a specific unanswered issue that helps people understand the proposal.

Could you give people a chance to clarify a question before voting starts? A short headline may attract support while a more detailed but useful question needs editing to be understandable. Agree wording with its author rather than changing what it asks.

Reserved slots give the moderator a way to choose comfortable questions and call them necessary. The ranking has the advantage of being visible.

That's a real concern. State what the reserved slots are for, such as covering relevant issues not yet addressed, and explain the choices. You could also publish the submitted questions in an agreed form without personal details. A mixed process needs visible accountability of its own.

Join the discussion

More in Politics