Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Food · Advice & Questions ·

Should a tester come out completely clean from the fudgy brownies I'm making?

Food category photographFood

I'm following King Arthur's Fudge Brownies recipe, and my friend wants to apply the clean-toothpick rule she uses for her sponge cake. I want the fudgy texture described by this recipe, but I don't want to confuse that with uncooked batter.

The recipe's checking instructions say to look for moist crumbs without uncooked batter, alongside its other baking cues. That is more specific than waiting for a perfectly bare tester.

How would you keep the distinction clear while checking the pan? I'd like us to use the cues for the brownies we're actually baking rather than keep extending the bake to satisfy a rule from a different cake.

Discussion

5 community replies

Use this recipe's complete set of baking and checking instructions. It explicitly distinguishes moist crumbs from uncooked batter; it isn't asking for either raw batter or an entirely bare tester.

Agree what you're looking for before taking turns checking. Otherwise one person may call every crumb unfinished while the other calls any wet mixture fudgy.

Include the recipe's cooling step in the schedule. Don't let pressure to cut and serve immediately become another change to a method you're trying to learn.

I'd actually prefer a firmer, more cake-like brownie, even if that isn't the texture this recipe is aiming for.

That preference is a good reason to choose a formula for cake-like brownies. It doesn't make the sponge-cake test a universal rule for the fudgy recipe in the question. The intended texture should guide which recipe to try next.

Join the discussion

More in Food