Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Politics · Advice & Questions ·

Should a nonpartisan civic forum ask the audience to remove party badges?

Politics category photographPolitics

I'm helping host a civic forum where representatives with different views will answer questions about local services. Our volunteers won't wear party branding. A co-host now wants to ask audience members to remove party badges too, so the room looks neutral in photographs.

One attendee says they came to listen and won't distribute anything, but don't want to take off their badge. The co-host worries visible clusters of supporters could make other people feel the room belongs to a party.

For this voluntary event, I'd rather set clear rules about interrupting, distributing material and treating speakers respectfully. But would allowing audience badges weaken the hosts' promise of a nonpartisan event? I'm asking about the event policy we should choose, rather than asserting a legal right to wear a badge.

Discussion

5 community replies

Nonpartisan hosting doesn't require every attendee to arrive without a political preference. Explain who organised the event and how questions are handled; a photograph of a bare lapel isn't much evidence of fair hosting.

The co-host's concern about the atmosphere is understandable. A quiet badge and an organised effort to dominate the room can look related, so you need a way to address the latter without treating everyone wearing a badge as disruptive.

If you choose a restriction, communicate it before attendance and apply it consistently. An improvised request at the door would put volunteers in avoidable arguments about what counts as party branding.

Would a request for no badges be acceptable if it were optional? It could express the atmosphere the hosts hope for without becoming a condition of entry.

Only if 'optional' really means someone can decline without being singled out. I would still explain the reason and decide beforehand how the hosts will handle campaigning or disruption. An optional clothing request cannot do that work by itself.

Join the discussion

More in Politics