Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Politics · Advice & Questions ·

Should a candidate's recorded answers get the same slot as live answers at our forum?

Politics category photographPolitics

One candidate invited to our nonpartisan forum cannot attend and has offered recorded answers to the questions we sent everyone. The recording would have the same speaking limit as the live answers. The organiser thinks playing it is fairer than leaving an empty place.

Other candidates would still face the moderator's follow-up questions. The recording cannot respond to those, and showing it later in the evening would also interrupt the live exchange. We didn't settle an absence policy before sending invitations.

Would you include the recording with its limits explained, offer everyone a separate recorded introduction, or keep this particular forum entirely live? I want residents to hear the candidate's position without presenting unlike opportunities as though they are identical.

Discussion

5 community replies

I'd tell the audience exactly what the recording can and can't do. It can give an answer to the original question; it can't take part in the follow-up exchange. A clear introduction would help readers of any later recording too.

The candidates who made time to attend have a reasonable point about the extra questioning. I'd ask them about the proposed format before deciding, without giving any one candidate a veto over the whole event.

Was the absence unavoidable, or was this simply the offered format? You don't need a public investigation of the candidate's private circumstances, but the organisers should understand what accommodation they're trying to make.

I'd rather hear the recorded position than nothing. Residents lose useful information if an empty chair is the only permitted response to an absence.

I'd want to hear it too, but perhaps in a clearly separate segment or alongside written answers. That would preserve the information while keeping the audience aware of who actually took part in the live questioning.

Join the discussion

More in Politics