Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Politics · Advice & Questions ·

Our politics group wants to share a report summary none of us has checked against the report

Politics category photographPolitics

The summary has headings, confident conclusions, and page references. Our politics group wants to circulate it as a guide to a public-policy report. When I asked who had checked the passages, the room went quiet.

One member received the summary from someone outside the group. I have read the report's introduction, which isn't enough to vouch for the account. Another member says the references are the verification: why include page numbers if the claims aren't there?

I don't want to label the summary wrong without checking it. I also don't want our group's name to turn a second-hand account into something we've independently established.

What should we verify before sharing, and what can we honestly offer if we don't have time to assess the whole report?

Discussion

5 community replies

Check the passages behind the claims you intend to repeat, including nearby qualifications and the report's stated scope. A page reference tells you where to look; it doesn't establish what you'll find there.

Keep the outside summary distinct from the report's own wording. If you quote the report, use the text you actually checked rather than putting quotation marks around a paraphrase received from someone else.

I'd ask where the summary came from and what purpose it was written for. It may be selective without containing a single invented sentence. Knowing its purpose would help you decide how to use it.

You may not need to produce a guide to the whole report. A short note about a few claims the group has checked could be more useful than delaying indefinitely or endorsing the complete summary.

That gives you a workable scope. Identify the passages examined and the questions still open, and link readers to the original report. Don't let checking a few points turn into a claim that the whole second-hand account has passed review.

Join the discussion

More in Politics