Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Politics · Advice & Questions ·

Our planning discussion speaks for current residents. Who considers people who might live here later?

Politics category photographPolitics

At a discussion of converting an empty office building into flats, someone said, "The people who live here are the people who matter." I understood the frustration behind it. Current residents would live through any disruption and changes around the site.

I also kept thinking about people who might want those homes but weren't in the room. I don't know who they would be, whether this scheme would meet their needs, or whether it is a good proposal overall. I don't want to invent a grateful future resident to win an argument.

How can a local discussion take absent and future interests seriously while still hearing the people already affected? I want a way to examine that gap, not a reason to declare either the existing neighbours or the proposed residents the only legitimate concern.

Discussion

5 community replies

Name the interests the discussion needs to examine without pretending you know the future occupants' views. Existing neighbours' concerns and the potential use of new homes can both be relevant to assessing the proposal.

Ask what evidence the planning papers provide about the need the development is meant to meet. That is a better starting point than choosing an imagined household whose story conveniently settles the question.

People who currently live elsewhere but are looking for housing may have something to contribute. Check the participation arrangements before assuming the conversation must be limited to the nearest neighbours.

Be careful with "future residents would want this." They might value the homes, dislike the layout, or need something the proposal doesn't offer. Absence shouldn't become permission to supply them with a unanimous opinion.

Exactly. Treat the gap as a reason to seek relevant evidence and hear a wider range of views where the process permits. You can consider possible benefits and costs without claiming an endorsement from people who haven't spoken.

Join the discussion

More in Politics