Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Politics · Advice & Questions ·

Our committee rejected my proposal but reused one of its ideas. Should it give credit?

Politics category photographPolitics

Our civic committee rejected my proposed public workshop because the whole programme would cost too much. Its new plan uses the neighbourhood map I suggested as a way to collect questions. I'm pleased that part may happen, but the draft announcement describes it as the committee's new idea.

I don't want credit to imply that I endorse the whole replacement plan, and I don't think using one good element means the original rejection must have been wrong. I'd still like a simple acknowledgement of where that element came from.

Would asking for that look like trying to reopen the decision? I'm asking about fair acknowledgement within our group, rather than claiming legal ownership of an idea.

Discussion

5 community replies

Ask for credit for the specific contribution: 'The question-map idea came from the earlier proposal.' You can be precise without relitigating the full programme.

Make clear whether you want the map used, if that has been left uncertain, and whether the announcement is suggesting you support the replacement. Attribution and endorsement needn't be bundled together.

The committee may have focused so hard on making an affordable plan that it didn't think about the origin of each element. A direct request gives it a chance to correct the announcement without an accusation.

I can see the committee worrying that the acknowledgement will sound like admitting it should have accepted the original proposal.

Credit doesn't require that conclusion. The announcement can acknowledge the map idea while the decision record still explains why the full programme wasn't chosen. A proposal can contain something useful without being workable as a whole.

Join the discussion

More in Politics