Our civic workshop filled before I finished work. Is first-come-first-served the fairest way?
PoliticsThe invitation arrived in the morning. When I opened it after my shift, every workshop place was taken.
The organisers want residents to discuss priorities for the town plan. They say first-come-first-served avoids choosing favourites. I understand the attraction of a clear rule. But being quick to open an email doesn't seem especially connected to having something useful to contribute.
I'm not asking them to remove someone so I can attend. I'm helping with a later session, where we could set an application window and decide how to allocate places afterwards. A colleague worries that a draw would frustrate people who took the trouble to reply promptly.
What would be a fair arrangement for limited places, and how should we describe what the workshop can speak for whichever method we choose?