Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Politics · Advice & Questions ·

Our civic group's vote tied. Is it fair to suggest a coin toss now?

Politics category photographPolitics

Our small civic group split evenly between two topics for its next public workshop. After the result, someone suggested tossing a coin so we could book a facilitator that evening. Before voting, we'd never discussed how to resolve a tie, and nobody has yet checked whether our rules say anything about it.

Both topics could make a useful event. I like the speed and apparent impartiality of a coin toss, but another member says a random result would leave the group without an agreed choice. Would you pause to establish the proper next step, even if that risks losing the booking? I don't want to assume either that the chair has a casting vote or that an improvised tie-break becomes fair just because the coin itself is fair.

Discussion

5 community replies

Check the existing rules first. They may already settle what happens after a tie.

Random selection can be reasonable when the group has accepted it for a choice like this. The concern here is adopting it after people have voted under an unclear process.

Ask whether a short further discussion could produce a different proposal: perhaps one topic now and a definite date to consider the other. Don't promise a second event unless the group has the capacity to run it.

If both sides now agree to a coin toss, I'd accept it. Losing the facilitator over a tie-break seems a high price when either workshop would work.

If your rules permit that route and the agreement is freely given, it could be a practical resolution. Let people raise objections without being blamed for the lost booking, and record the agreed method before the toss. The deadline should explain the urgency, not manufacture consent.

Join the discussion

More in Politics