Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Politics · Advice & Questions ·

Our civic award criteria changed after nominations closed. Should we restart the process?

Politics category photographPolitics

We invited nominations for our association’s civic award using criteria about practical local service. After nominations closed, the panel added a requirement that the work must have involved more than one neighbourhood. Several otherwise eligible nominations would now fall outside the award.

The panel says the new condition better reflects the association’s purpose and will stop the prize becoming too local to one street. I can understand that aim. But people submitted nominations against a different description, and some may have chosen not to nominate work that would fit the new one.

Would you use the published criteria for this round, reopen nominations, or start again under a revised award? There is already an event booking, but no winner has been chosen. I want to weigh that inconvenience without treating it as a complete answer to the fairness problem.

Discussion

5 community replies

First ask why the change is needed now rather than for the next round. A useful improvement to an award’s purpose doesn’t automatically justify applying it after people have acted on the original invitation.

If you reopen, make the revised terms and the new opportunity clear to everyone you invited originally. Quietly letting only existing nominees adapt would leave the problem described in place.

Check what the association’s published process allows and explain any correction openly. Don’t present a new eligibility condition as if it had always been part of the invitation.

Restarting could disappoint nominees and waste the work of volunteers who have already prepared the event.

Include those costs in the choice. The association might keep the event while changing when it announces a winner, or complete this round under the original criteria. The important question is which option treats applicants fairly, not whether a restart is costless.

Join the discussion

More in Politics