Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Politics · Advice & Questions ·

Our choir bans party campaigning. Does that stop us discussing a council hall-charge proposal?

Politics category photographPolitics

The committee put the council's proposed hall charges on the agenda. A member pointed to our choir's rule against party campaigning and said the subject had to come off.

The charges could affect where we rehearse. I don't want rehearsals turned into arguments about which party people support, but I don't see how we can plan the choir's year without discussing a public decision that affects the room.

Some members want a joint response to the council. Others only want the committee to compare our options. We haven't agreed whether the choir would take any collective position.

How should we distinguish the practical discussion, an authorised response, and party campaigning without assuming that calling something political either forbids it or gives it an automatic place in every rehearsal?

Discussion

5 community replies

Read the actual rule and agree what it covers. A ban on party campaigning and a ban on discussing anything a council does are different boundaries. The committee shouldn't silently substitute one for the other.

Start with the effect on the choir and the choices it needs to make. Use the actual proposal and relevant costs, rather than letting the discussion become an assessment of every party's record.

I'd set aside a clearly described meeting for it. Members should be able to attend a rehearsal expecting to sing, even if a separate discussion about the room is necessary.

A collective response needs its own authorisation. Discussing the charge doesn't mean everyone has agreed to sign an objection in the choir's name.

Make that distinction explicit in the agenda: first understand the effect, then decide whether any response is wanted and who can approve it under the choir's rules. Members can help plan for the charge without being presented as supporters of a political statement they haven't agreed to.

Join the discussion

More in Politics