Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Career / Work · Advice & Questions ·

My review has a wrong date and a judgment I dispute. Should I challenge them together?

Career / Work category photographCareer / Work

My annual review says I missed a client handover deadline on 14 June. The agreed date in the project email was 21 June, and we handed over on the 20th. I can show that without much argument.

The same paragraph says I was reluctant to take ownership. I disagree with that too, but it's a judgment rather than a date I can correct with one email. My manager points to me asking who could approve a change in scope; I thought that was responsible rather than reluctant.

I have been asked to add my comments before the review is finalised. Should I submit one response saying the whole paragraph is unfair, or ask for the date to be corrected and discuss the assessment separately? I'm worried that focusing on the easy factual point will leave the bigger impression unchallenged.

Discussion

5 community replies

Separate the two requests in the same response. Attach the agreed deadline and ask for that sentence to be corrected. Then explain why you disagree with the ownership assessment and ask which actions would have met the expected standard. Neither issue needs to disappear for the other to be discussed.

The scope question needs context: what change was proposed, what authority you had and what you did while waiting. I'd bring those details rather than only saying “asking is responsible”. Your manager may be using a different definition of ownership, and you need to find out what it is.

Ask how the factual correction affects the judgment. If the missed deadline was the main evidence for reluctance, correcting it should prompt a fresh conversation about that reasoning. If there were other examples, ask to discuss them specifically.

Could treating the judgment separately make it sound as though you're accepting it? I would want my disagreement recorded before clicking anything that finalises the review.

You can state that disagreement explicitly while making two distinct requests. Also ask what the finalisation or acknowledgement step means in your employer's process and how your response will be retained. Separating fact from assessment makes your challenge clearer; it doesn't require you to endorse the assessment.

Join the discussion

More in Career / Work