Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Career / Work · Advice & Questions ·

My probation is being extended, but “more confidence” is the only target I've been given

Career / Work category photographCareer / Work

At my probation review, my manager said she wanted another six weeks to feel confident in me. I asked which work needed improving. She said there hadn't been one big problem, but she needed to see me become more established.

I'm in an operations job in England. I can work on a specific gap, and I'd rather have support than be told everything is fine when it isn't. What I can't do is tell whether “more established” means faster work, better decisions or simply more time in the team.

The original probation period hasn't ended yet. What should I ask to have set out before the extension begins? I want a useful plan and a fair chance to respond, without making the conversation sound like I refuse to hear concerns.

Discussion

5 community replies

Ask for the reason, expectations and review arrangements in writing. Acas's probation-extension guidance says the employer and employee should discuss the extension's length, review points, improvement expectations, support and possible outcomes. That gives you a concrete basis for asking what “more confidence” will look like in this job, rather than trying to disprove an undefined impression.

Bring a few examples of completed work and ask your manager to identify what she would have wanted done differently. This isn't about presenting a defence bundle; it is a way to turn a broad concern into something you can understand and act on.

Request a check-in partway through, not only a verdict at the end. If an expectation is being interpreted differently, you both need time to correct course. Also ask which training, access or decisions from others the plan depends on.

Could asking for measurable targets make the review too narrow? Some of a role is judgment and how you work with people, rather than a number.

Those can be discussed through examples too. Ask what decisions you should handle, what communication is expected and how progress will be reviewed. You don't need to turn every expectation into a score, but both of you should be able to explain what improvement would mean.

Join the discussion

More in Career / Work