Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Career / Work · Advice & Questions ·

My old employer paid me again after I left

Career / Work category photographCareer / Work

A salary payment arrived from my former employer after my employment ended. It looks like the usual monthly amount, but I haven't received an explanation of whether it includes final adjustments.

I worked in England. Payroll has now emailed asking me to return the payment, without a breakdown. I haven't spent it. A friend says their mistake is their problem, while I want to understand what was actually owed before either keeping or returning the whole sum.

What should I ask payroll to reconcile? I want to resolve a genuine overpayment, including the effect of any deductions, without accepting an unexplained figure simply because it came in a repayment request.

Discussion

5 community replies

An employer's payroll mistake does not generally make the money yours to keep. Acas says employers can usually recover overpayments, including after someone has left, and should explain why money is owed and how much. Ask for that calculation before agreeing the amount. Acas guidance.

Request a reconciliation showing the employment end date, pay period, any final adjustments, deductions and the amount actually transferred. Compare it with your final payslip and leaving documents. A payment after leaving may need explaining before you can tell how much was an error.

You can respond promptly without conceding an unverified total: “I have kept the payment available. Please send the calculation so we can agree the correct repayment.” Keep the correspondence and confirmation of any repayment together.

What if payroll asks for the gross salary, but the employee only received the amount after tax and other deductions? Sending back the larger figure could be a very different burden.

Ask payroll to explain that difference and how the deductions and records will be corrected before transferring an agreed sum. Don't assume gross and net are interchangeable, or invent the tax correction yourself. If the calculation remains disputed, get advice on the actual payslips and request rather than ignoring it. Acas overpayment guidance.

Join the discussion

More in Career / Work