Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Neighbours · Advice & Questions ·

My neighbour wants to count every bird visit. How do I keep our survey practice useful?

Neighbours category photographNeighbours

My neighbour invited me to spend an hour in his garden practising for a future RSPB Big Garden Birdwatch. We aren't submitting this practice count. He kept adding another tally whenever a bird landed, including when the same species returned several times.

The RSPB's published how-to guide says to record the highest number of each species seen at one time, rather than add up visits. When I pointed that out, he said the lower figure would make his garden look empty and that I couldn't prove the returning birds were the same individuals.

I can't identify individual birds either, which seems a good reason to use the method rather than guess. He enjoyed making a busy list, and I don't want to spoil that. How can I suggest practising the survey count accurately while still enjoying everything we see? We can check the next survey's instructions and dates when they are available.

Discussion

5 community replies

The guide's method doesn't require either of you to recognise individual birds. For each species, keep the largest group you see together. His point that you can't prove who returned doesn't prevent you following that rule.

You could keep two records during practice: a diary of visits for his enjoyment and the count the survey asks for. Label them clearly. A busy diary and a smaller simultaneous count can both describe the hour without being interchangeable results.

I would take 'empty' seriously as the part he is reacting to. The survey number isn't a score for how good his garden is. You can enjoy repeated visits without needing the submitted figure to include every landing.

Perhaps let him keep his visit list and do the survey-style count yourself for now. He invited you into his garden; spending the whole hour correcting his tally would make the hobby fairly joyless.

That works for a practice session if you agree what each list means. When you take part in the actual survey, decide beforehand which record you are submitting and follow that edition's instructions. Quietly keeping a second list won't help if you later disagree over which total to send.

Join the discussion

More in Neighbours