Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Career / Work · Advice & Questions ·

My manager wants me to paste applicants' CVs into an AI tool we haven't approved

Career / Work category photographCareer / Work

We're recruiting for a coordinator at a small company in England. My manager sent me a link to a general AI website and asked me to paste the applicants' CVs into it, then get a best-to-worst ranking before our shortlisting meeting.

I haven't uploaded anything. I don't know whether the company has approved the tool, what happens to the documents or what criteria the ranking would use. My manager says I can remove the names and that we'd still make the final decision ourselves.

I can see why she wants help getting through the applications. I'm not opposed to using an approved tool for an agreed purpose, but I don't feel equipped to decide this one is appropriate. How do I raise the questions without sounding as though I'm refusing to help with recruitment, and what useful alternative can I offer for this round?

Discussion

5 community replies

The ICO's published questions for recruitment AI cover privacy assessment, processing responsibilities, fairness and information given to candidates. Those are questions for an agreed organisational process. I'd ask the recruitment or data-protection lead to confirm the tool and purpose before sending real applications to it, rather than taking approval from a link in a message.

Offer to build a shortlisting sheet from the role's agreed requirements and review the applications against it. Your manager can help decide the criteria and how uncertain cases will be discussed. That advances this round of recruitment while the tool question gets a proper answer.

Ask what “best” is supposed to mean before discussing the technology. If the team hasn't agreed what evidence matters for this coordinator job, a ranked list won't resolve that disagreement. It may only make a judgment look settled before the panel has examined it.

If you remove names and the panel reviews everything anyway, isn't this just a rough aid? I can understand the manager thinking a full approval discussion is disproportionate.

Removing names doesn't answer the separate questions about what other information would be sent, how the provider uses it or why a candidate gets a particular rank. Human review needs an agreed method too. For a trial, I'd propose invented sample applications and no hiring decisions while the responsible people assess the tool.

Join the discussion

More in Career / Work