Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Career / Work · Advice & Questions ·

My manager says a broken printer will come out of my next wages

Career / Work category photographCareer / Work

I work in England and accidentally knocked a printer off a low stand while moving a trolley. I reported it straight away. The manager has now sent me the price of a brand-new replacement and said that amount will be taken from my next wages.

I accept that I caused the accident. I haven't agreed to the deduction, and I don't know whether the printer could be repaired or what our contract says about damage. There hasn't been a discussion about how the accident happened.

How do I ask them to check the proposed deduction without sounding as though I'm denying what I did? I need to understand the basis and the amount before payroll runs.

Discussion

5 community replies

Reporting an accident isn't the same as agreeing that any proposed wage deduction is lawful. Acas explains the permitted bases, including a specific contractual provision or prior written agreement in relevant cases. Ask which basis they rely on and for the relevant wording; don't assume fresh consent is always required or that any damage clause settles every issue. Acas guidance.

Separate the incident from the price. “I reported that I knocked it over. Please explain how the proposed amount was calculated and whether repair was assessed.” An honest account of what happened doesn't require you to endorse an unexplained replacement figure.

Request a pause while the basis and amount are checked, and ask when payroll will be processed. Keep your report, the manager's message and the contract wording together. If they won't resolve it, those details will make a conversation with Acas or your union more useful than simply saying the deduction feels unfair.

Would offering smaller instalments be a sensible compromise? Losing the whole amount in one pay period could be the immediate problem.

Instalments might help if a deduction is properly established and you agree the arrangement. They don't answer whether this deduction is permitted or whether the amount is right. Clarify those questions first, then discuss timing without presenting the proposal as acceptance of the full replacement charge.

Join the discussion

More in Career / Work