Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Confessions · Advice & Questions ·

My friend told me he may withdraw as best man. My brother keeps asking me whether the speech is going well

Confessions category photographConfessions

My friend said he was having doubts about being best man at my brother's wedding and asked me to keep the conversation private while he thought. I agreed.

When my brother later asked whether everything was going well, I said the speech was coming along. I hadn't seen a draft or asked about it. I wanted to protect the private conversation, so I supplied progress I didn't know existed.

Now my brother is arranging the speeches and asking me for another update. My friend hasn't told me he's definitely withdrawing; he has told me he isn't sure. I don't want to announce a decision he hasn't made or keep inventing reassurance until somebody else discovers the gap.

What can I say honestly to both of them? I'd like to respect uncertainty without becoming the person who makes an uncertain commitment sound settled.

Discussion

5 community replies

Correct the progress claim: you haven't seen the speech and shouldn't have described it as coming along. Your brother can ask the person giving it directly. That correction doesn't require you to narrate every private doubt your friend shared.

Tell your friend that keeping his feelings private doesn't mean you can provide invented updates. Ask him to communicate directly about any change that affects the arrangements, rather than making you manage the space between what he feels and what your brother expects.

Having doubts is not the same as deciding to withdraw. Don't replace your earlier unsupported reassurance with an equally definite announcement that the speech won't happen.

You can explain what you will say if asked again: you don't know the progress and aren't coordinating the speech. That gives your friend a clear limit on your involvement without deciding the role on his behalf.

The limit needs to remain truthful when the next question arrives. Avoid another optimistic guess to postpone the awkwardness. Let the two people making the commitment discuss it, while you own the assurance you supplied without knowing.

Join the discussion

More in Confessions